10 Reasons Why Your Eye Makeup Looks MUDDY!

10 Reasons Why Your Eye Makeup Looks MUDDY!

September 22, 20224 min read

10 Reasons why your eye makeup looks MUDDY!

Have you ever finished your makeup and wondered, Why does my eye makeup look muddy and splotchy... just plain yucky... when I'm using the same colors I've used before? Or I'm doing everything SHE is doing in the tutorial!

If you've ever used more than one eye shadow shade, you have probably had this frustration. I'm here today to explain the TOP TEN reasons why your eye makeup looks muddy! 

Here we go...

10 Reasons why your eye makeup looks MUDDY!

With every episode of Michelle Fox Beauty I like to provide a FREE resource for you! 

Click HERE to get 12 Tips for Perfect Eye Shadow Application!

12 Tips for Perfect Eyeshadow Application

10 Reasons Why Your Eye Makeup Looks MUDDY:

#10  Not using a quality palette.

You get what you pay for! Make sure you are using the best quality eye makeup you can afford.

#9  Using the wrong colors.

The combination of colors is definitely a factor in the final outcome. Add to that, your eyes, hair and complexion may look better in some color families and not look good at all in others. 

Knowing which colors work together and flatter you takes some trial and error. When in doubt, ask an expert for guidance!  (that's me!)

#8  Not blending properly.

Blending is always key in your makeup application. Don't make the mistake of neglecting to blend the edges of your eye look. The purpose is to soften the look and make the transition more natural. 

On the other side, if you blend too much, especially if you drag colors from one area to another, you are very likely to end up with a muddy, blotchy mess!

#7  Not using the correct technique.

Even though you are using (or should be) brushes, the motion is not a brushing back and forth motion but rather a patting on of the color. This gives you better color  pay-off and more precise control over placement. 

#6  Using too much product.

Less is more when it comes to makeup application. You can easily add more color if you need it, but removing excess color is almost impossible.  You usually have to take everything off and start over. And nobody has time for that!

#5  Not considering your eye shape and size.

Your eyes are not the exact size and shape of the YouTuber you are watching or the photo you found online. You have to adjust your technique (and your expectations) according to what you have to work with.

#4 Trying a look that is too complicated.

You may be trying something that you aren't quite ready for. Some eye  makeup looks found on Pinterest have been created by top makeup artists with years of experience. Slow your roll, as they say, and try something a little bit simpler.

Here come the TOP 3 reasons why your eye makeup looks MUDDY...

#3  Not using different brushes.

If you are using the same brush for every color that you dip in to, the brush will combine all those shades into one splotchy muddy color! 

You need a variety of brushes for eye makeup application. 

One benefit of using a different brush for each shade is that you can choose the size and shape of the bristles based on how and where you want the color deposited. 

When you have specific brushes for your highlight, mid-tone, and contour shades, plus one to use as a liner, one for blending and so on, the eye color on each brush stays true and the final look is easier to achieve and much more flattering.

#2 Not using eye primer. 

It's a crime not to prime!

Eye primer has so many benefits. I never skip this step!

Eye primer:

  • gives the shadow something to cling to so application is easier

  • provides a more intense, truer color pay off

  • prevents shadow from creasing and fading throughout the day

  • makes lids appear smoother

  • allows easier blending 

  • some have ingredients such as retinol palmitate that fight crepiness

And the #1 Reason why your eye shadow looks MUDDY is...

#1 Dirty brushes!!!

If you are using your brushes for a variety of colors and textures over a long period of time, all of those pigments are combining and affect every application that you do! 

Add to that the dead skin, oil and bacteria that are in those bristles, and you have LOTS of great reasons to regularly clean your brushes! Once a week is suggested.

Remember to let your brushes dry either horizontally off the edge of a counter or upside-down so the water doesn't seep into the barrel where the glue is located! Water will weaken the bond and your bristles will fall out. 

Wrap up...

Did you have an "a-ha" moment? Which of these 10 reasons is your personal saboteur? 

Be sure to let us know in the comments what you think about these 10 reasons; whether you make any changes to your eye makeup routine; and of course, your results!

I help women 50+ make simple, effective changes to their skincare & makeup so they can look and feel their best.

Michelle Fox

I help women 50+ make simple, effective changes to their skincare & makeup so they can look and feel their best.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog

Hello beautiful!

Here are a few ways that I like to serve my followers and customers. Jump in wherever you are most comfortable!

Beauty Through the Ages

JOIN MY PRIVATE FACEBOOK COMMUNITY ESPECIALLY FOR MATuRE BEAUTY LOVERS!

Get insider info, live tutorials, free samples, special offers, product giveaways, birthday discounts, and so much more!

Foundation Finder

DISCOVER YOUR PERFECT MATCH...

FOUNDATION SHADE, THAT IS!

Figuring out your foundation undertone, formula, and finish can be daunting! Take the guesswork out of it by answering a few simple questions to reveal the foundation shade and type that is just right for you! Email me your results for 20% off your first order*!

[email protected]

*participants must be over 18, a resident of the United States, and not currently working with me or any other Mary Kay Beauty Consultant.

Shop with Confidence

try THE BEST-SELLING DIRECT SALES brand of skincare & cosmetics IN THE WORLD!

I tried Mary Kay for the first time in 1982 and I've been using it ever since! If you don't currently have a Mary Kay Beauty Consultant and you are over 18 and a resident of the United States, I invite you to shop with me. Everything is 100% satisfaction guaranteed and shipping is always free! Get 20% off your first order by adding promo code NEWCUST to the comments area!

Join my Team

IF YOU LOVE "ALL THINGS BEAUTY",

YOU MAY ENJOY DOING WHAT I DO!

Becoming an Independent Beauty Consultant is simple and we provide all of the training and support you need to get started. Click the button below to get more information or send your questions to me at [email protected].

Shop Our Swag!

Super cute t-shirts, mugs, water bottles and so much more for beauty lovers, Boss Babes, and anyone who considers herself Forever Young.

Visit my Amazon Shop!

Beauty - Home - Fashion - Health - Pets

Like Ipsy, but FREE!

Get a free, no obligation beauty bundle !

In addition to being a blogger and content creator, I am a skincare and cosmetics consultant to hundreds of women. I would love to send you customized samples to see if you would like to become one of them. The first step is to answer a few quick questions about your skin type & shade preferences. Click the button to begin!

AGE-REVERSING BEAUTY HACKS

Your Ultimate Guide to Radiant Skin

The beauty secrets that helped me

navigate menopause and beyond!

COPYRIGHT © 2025 · MICHELLE FOX ONLINE | PRIVACY POLICY | TERMS & CONDITIONS