Eyeshadow Finishes - matte, shimmer, and so much more!

Eyeshadow Finishes - matte, shimmer, and so much more!

September 15, 20234 min read

Eyeshadow finishes are available in matte, shimmer, glitter, and so much more! What's even more exciting to me is that mature eyes can wear more finishes than just "matte". Our shade options with matte finishes are somewhat limited, and matte eyeshadow can be challenging to blend. Women over 50 tend to stick with matte despite these challenges because the alternative, shimmery finishes, can emphasize the crepey texture of our eyelids. So what's a girl to do when she wants some pizzazz? That's what we will discuss in this week's blog. You can wear more than matte, and I will show you how!

Did you catch my previous blog, 12 Simple Eyeshadow Application Tips

Eyeshadow Finishes for Mature Eyes - so much more than matte!

Watch the video!

Have you subscribed to my YouTube channel yet?

 

Grab your FREE copy of 12 Tips for Perfect Eye Shadow Application right here!

12 Tips for Perfect Eyeshadow Application

Keep these 12 application tips handy for those moments when your eye makeup doesn't look quite right and you aren't sure why!

CLICK HERE

Eyeshadow Finishes

The "finish" of your eyeshadow is the amount of reflection coming from tiny mica pieces of differing sizes. 

Finishes can be any of the following:

  • mate - no shimmer at all

  • shimmer - some reflection

  • satin - a combination of matter and shimmer

  • frost/pearl - mostly opaque with lots of reflection

  • metallic - even more reflection

  • glitter - the most reflection

  • matte with glitter - a matte base with glitter over it

More about Matte - 

matte

A matte finish is similar to flat paint. There is no reflection at all coming from mica or anything else! Matte shades often have a lot of pigment, which can actually make them a little more challenging to blend. (Here's a beauty hack to know if your matte shadow will blend well or not! Rub your finger in the sample pan and if the eyeshadow tranfers easily to your finger, it will likely blend well.)

Matte is the finish most often recommended for women with aging, textured eyelids. The smooth finish does not accentuate crepeyness in the eyelid area. 

*I have some of my favorite matte palettes listed at the end of the blog!

More about Shimmer - 

shimmer

Shimmer is extremely popular for lots of reasons! Tiny mica pieces reflect the light for a subtle glow. Shimmery eyeshadows are usually easier to blend and come in a huge variety of shades. 

Traditionally, women with mature eyes are told to stay away from shimmer because the mica gathers in the crepey eyelid grooves and draws attention to the area. 

A blend of the two - Satin!

satin

I recently got an eyeshadow quad from F.A.R.A.H. and decided to try the shimmery highlight shade. It is a gorgeous champagne color and I was thrilled that it applies very smoothly, much like a matte shade. The shimmer was very subtle, almost unnoticeable unless light was directly on my lids. 

I wore it all day and filmed a video while wearning this amazing mix of matte and shimmer. I thought it looked amazing! What was happening?!!

As I read more about eyeshadow finishes, I discovered that a satin finish is actually a combination of matte and shimmer that is very "wearable" for just about everyone, regardless of age! Yay!!!

F.A.R.A.H. eyeshadow quad in Sugarplum is only available on the F.A.R.A.H. website.

F.A.R.A.H. Sugarplum

F.A.R.A.H. eyeshadow quad in Sugar Plum

And a few more options...

If you love some drama with your eyemakeup, then these finishes are for you: pearl (also called "frost), metallic, glitter, and matte with glitter,

frost

metallic

glitter

matte with glitter

Keep in mind that using an eye primer and clean makeup brushes will help any finish look better! (Have you read 8 Reasons Why Your Eye Makeup Looks Muddy?) However you may want to skip the brush altogether when applying extremely shimmery or glittery shades. Often times, the best way to apply them is by using your middle finger, patting the shadow onto your lid. 

Favorite Matte Palettes

I mention in the video that I only used matte eyeshadow for many years and so I've got a few favorite palettes that I would like to share with anyone searching for some new matte shades!

Tartelette™ Amazonian clay matte palette

SmashBox Cover Shot Eye Palette in matte

Urban Decay Naked2 Basics Eye Palette

Mary Kay Chromafusion eyeshadow, matte

Wrap Up

I, for one, am super excited to know that I have more options than just a matte finish that will flatter my eyes and I can't wait to try more satin finishes! Let me know in the comments what your current faves are! 

I help women 50+ make simple, effective changes to their skincare & makeup so they can look and feel their best.

Michelle Fox

I help women 50+ make simple, effective changes to their skincare & makeup so they can look and feel their best.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog

Hello beautiful!

Here are a few ways that I like to serve my followers and customers. Jump in wherever you are most comfortable!

Beauty Through the Ages

JOIN MY PRIVATE FACEBOOK COMMUNITY ESPECIALLY FOR MATuRE BEAUTY LOVERS!

Get insider info, live tutorials, free samples, special offers, product giveaways, birthday discounts, and so much more!

Foundation Finder

DISCOVER YOUR PERFECT MATCH...

FOUNDATION SHADE, THAT IS!

Figuring out your foundation undertone, formula, and finish can be daunting! Take the guesswork out of it by answering a few simple questions to reveal the foundation shade and type that is just right for you! Email me your results for 20% off your first order*!

[email protected]

*participants must be over 18, a resident of the United States, and not currently working with me or any other Mary Kay Beauty Consultant.

Shop with Confidence

try THE BEST-SELLING DIRECT SALES brand of skincare & cosmetics IN THE WORLD!

I tried Mary Kay for the first time in 1982 and I've been using it ever since! If you don't currently have a Mary Kay Beauty Consultant and you are over 18 and a resident of the United States, I invite you to shop with me. Everything is 100% satisfaction guaranteed and shipping is always free! Get 20% off your first order by adding promo code NEWCUST to the comments area!

Join my Team

IF YOU LOVE "ALL THINGS BEAUTY",

YOU MAY ENJOY DOING WHAT I DO!

Becoming an Independent Beauty Consultant is simple and we provide all of the training and support you need to get started. Click the button below to get more information or send your questions to me at [email protected].

Shop Our Swag!

Super cute t-shirts, mugs, water bottles and so much more for beauty lovers, Boss Babes, and anyone who considers herself Forever Young.

Visit my Amazon Shop!

Beauty - Home - Fashion - Health - Pets

Like Ipsy, but FREE!

Get a free, no obligation beauty bundle !

In addition to being a blogger and content creator, I am a skincare and cosmetics consultant to hundreds of women. I would love to send you customized samples to see if you would like to become one of them. The first step is to answer a few quick questions about your skin type & shade preferences. Click the button to begin!

AGE-REVERSING BEAUTY HACKS

Your Ultimate Guide to Radiant Skin

The beauty secrets that helped me

navigate menopause and beyond!

COPYRIGHT © 2025 · MICHELLE FOX ONLINE | PRIVACY POLICY | TERMS & CONDITIONS